Skip to main content

Book Review: The Boston Girl

2. The Boston Girl by Anita Diamant



My mom got me this book for Hanukkah, and we went to hear Anita Diamant talk about it this week. Diamant's comments really brought into focus what I thought about the book. She affirmed that her "MO" is to write about hidden women's stories-specifically, in this case, the stories of the women of Rockport Lodge. The book she said, began with the title "Rockport Lodge," though it came to be more about the protagonist Addie Baum, the type of grandmother Diamant says she wants to be, whose sharp wit and humor came in during later revisions of the book.

As an aspiring writer, I was interested in Diamant's hints about the writing process. She confirms what I teach my students when we read Anne Lamott's "Shitty First Drafts," --it takes a lot of revision to get to the final product! For me, the final product was a compulsively easy read. I slipped into the skin of the character, a young Jewish woman growing up in Boston in the early twentieth century, and remained there the whole time.

Addie Baum tells the story of her life, from memory, to her granddaughter. The dialogue is believable as memory, but still clean and easy to understand. No tangle of clauses to get lost in, words are direct, and punchy: "Italians are as good as Jews when it comes to guilt." Growing up, Addie is friends with a group who call themselves the "Mixed Nuts," made up of the early twentieth century's best-known immigrants: Italians, Irish, and Jews. It's heartening, though perhaps unrealistic, how she maintains these friendships into adulthood.

Although this book is drastically different from The Red Tent in subject matter and style, it does spring from a similar agenda. This is a tale about one woman's life, and through her, about a whole swath of women who have not been especially recognized in history. In this respect, the book is equally successful. Rockport Lodge, a vacation house for working women, features prominently in Addie's story. This was apparently a real place, where women in Massachusetts gathered and organized and supported each other, especially younger women and girls. Through this network of sisterhood, Addie becomes a successful reporter and member of society. Though she eventually marries and breeds with a nice Jewish boy, her story, and those of her sister Betty and her eclectic friends, is an inspiring one.

I enjoyed The Boston Girl, but it also left me feeling...like I hadn't learned or thought about anything new. The Red Tent was so revolutionary, and read at such a pivotal time in my life, that perhaps my expectations of Anita Diamant are far too high. The subject matter of the book is also extremely familiar to me, in a way that's comforting, but also stagnant.The story of Jews coming to America from the old country is, of course, my family's story, and while my family first stayed in New York, I have my own personal history with Boston. I especially enjoyed it when Addie's family moves to Roxbury. I once lived there, and I remember the churches festooned with Stars of David, which is how I learned it used to be a Jewish neighborhood (no longer, but Brookline, also mentioned, still is). On the other hand, I don't really need to be reminded of how good I have it that my parents didn't force me to work in a factory and then marry a nice Jewish boy they picked out.

Ron Charles' review in the Washington Post clarifies my feelings about the book: "World War I, the flu of 1918, the Minnesota orphan train, Southern lynchings — they’re all blanched in the warm bath of Addie’s sentimental narrative." The book does deal with some big issues, just not in a way that especially piques. Still, Diamant's mission in writing the stories of unknown women is appealing to me, and Diamant herself and her fiction are very relatable to me in particular, and I'm sure others coming from a similar Jewish immigrant background.

Recommended to fans of Jewish and women's fiction; also recommended to hear Anita Diamant speak if you can, definitely a worthwhile experience!

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Books with Single-Word Titles

Happy Top Ten Tuesday over at That Artsy Reader Girl! Books with Single-Word Titles These are all my favorite books that I could think of with one-word titles. A lot of fantasy, a few nonfiction (minus subtitles) and Kindred , whether you consider it scifi or historical fiction. Also two portmanteaus using the word "bitter." I suppose it's a word that lends itself to amelioration. 1. Sweetbitter by Stephanie Danler 2. Bitterblue by Kristin Cashore 3. Fire by Kristin Cashore 4. Heartless by Marissa Meyer 5. Inheritance by Christopher Paolini 6. Meditations by Marcus Aurelius 7. Stoned by Aja Raden (has a subtitle) 8. Educated by Tara Westover 9. Fledgling by Octavia Butler 10. Kindred by Octavia Butler

Feliz Ano Nuevo!

Speaking of cultures and society, I leave for Spain on January 9. Instead of continuing as a book blog with a specific goal for number of books to read in a year, Space Station Mir will become a chronicle for my adventures in Spain. Expect a post for each new place that I visit, with pictures! I also plan to continue reviewing books, however I will not make a set goal for number of books to read this year. I do pledge myself to read at least one book in Spanish that was not assigned for a class. In terms of my goals for 2009, I was not diligent enough in keeping track of them. Looking back, I've fulfilled some of them and not others. The greatest trend in my reading this year, which marks a huge deviation for me, is that I've read more non-fiction than I think I've read any other year in my life. I've finally developed the ability to sustain interest in non-fiction other than biographies. For a while, biographies were the only non-fiction I ever read, with the exception

Most Recent Books I Did Not Finish

 I feel like I've been DNFing a fair amount lately, mostly with review books. I feel obligated to read review books longer than I would if they were books I just picked up on my own. That said, I have a caveat in my Book Review Policy  that if I feel I am not the right audience for the book, I won't post a review. I try to avoid that by only picking books I genuinely think I will enjoy, but of course I can't always predict that before I read. Also, while book clubs have been a great way to get exposed to books I wouldn't normally read, tastes will differ and every once in a while, I find a book I'm just not willing to finish. I also want to say no shade to the authors or anyone who enjoyed these books--they just weren't for me. Happy Top Ten Tuesday! Most Recent Books I Did Not Finish 1. Caribbean Competitors by Poppy Minnix--LibraryThing review--This one sounded great and has a beautiful cover, but while the island setting was compelling, I just couldn't ge