Skip to main content

Book Review: The Shadow of Theron by Kathryn Troy

The Shadow of Theron by Kathryn Troy

Published February 28, 2023

Goodreads

Blurb (Provided by the Author)

The powers of old are fading. A new Age is dawning.

 Holy relics are all that remain of Theron's sacred legend. 

 Now those relics, the enchanted weapons forged by the Three-Faced Goddess to help Theron defeat the wicked Sorcerer Argoss, are disappearing.

 Lysandro knows the village magistrate Marek is responsible, and he searches for proof disguised as the masked protector the Shadow of Theron. 

But when Marek wounds him with an accursed sword that shouldn't exist, Lysandro must find a way to stop Marek from gaining any more artifacts created by the Goddess or her nemesis. The arrival of the beautiful newcomer Seraphine, with secrets of her own, only escalates their rivalry. 

As the feud between Lysandro and Marek throws Lighura into chaos, a pair of priestesses seeks to recover the relics and return them to safekeeping. But the stones warn that Argoss is returning, and they must race to retrieve Theron's most powerful weapon. But as they risk their lives for a legend, only one thing is certain. The three temples to the Goddess have been keeping secrets: not just from the faithful, but from each other.

 Wheel of Time readers and fans of Sarah Maas, Saladin Ahmed, and Trudy Canavan will delight in this fantasy adventure duology infused with romance. 

My Review:

I don't often say yes to book review requests these days, but this one ticked all of my boxes: Fantasy novel? Check. Strong female characters? Check. Assorted heroes on a hunt to retrieve mystical artifacts to defeat an apocalyptic villain? Check. 

This is classic familiar Hero's Journey stuff, comforting to any fantasy aficionado, but Troy has a lovely lush writing style and deftly meshes a Dungeons and Dragons type world with moments that seem more in tune with a contemporary fiction or romance novel. I found it utterly charming when the hero and heroine go on a date (via carriage, natch) to a museum, and of course, discover an ancient painting that holds a clue to a long-unsolved mystery. And of course, it felt refreshingly modern for the heroine to defend her beloved mystery novels, and when the hero takes her to a bookstore and buys her an entire stack of books. The more Dungeons and Dragons moments, complete with a sword that thrives on the blood of its victims, a warrior priestess that splits bad guys' heads like melons, and a mystical priestess (cleric?) that conjures all the runes, feel more grounded as a result, creating a world that feels exceptionally detailed.

Besides fantasy and romance novels, The Shadow of Theron echoes comic book tropes: the protagonist, Lysandro, also known as the Shadow of Theron, is a masked vigilante. Like Batman or Iron Man, Don Lysandro lives a double life as a pampered nobleman and eligible bachelor by day, and a defender of the people by night. His lady love, Seraphine, has a similar duality--sheltered noblewoman fresh home from a finishing school she did not actually attend, more intent on helping solve a mystery for her secret friends than finding a husband. Furthermore, the reader gets the villain's, Lothan Marek, perspective as well, sharing his dastardly deeds and unmitigated evil. Like many comic book villains, Lothan has no redeeming qualities and seems to exist only as an admittedly terrifying ultimate boss for the hero to defeat (we are talking literal godlike weapons and powers--hit points probably off the charts).

The Shadow of Theron contains a crowd of characters to root for and weaves moments of intricately imagined wonder and romance amid the more typical blood, guts, and high stakes of an epic fantasy novel. I don't personally care for having a villain's viewpoint when he is clearly irredeemable, but others may like the perspective his viewpoint gives on the many secrets of this world. I would definitely recommend the book to fellow fantasy readers, especially those who, like me, are also fans of other genres, and I eagerly await the sequel (also kind of excited that it's a duology so I get to know the end sooner than the more usual trilogy format!). 

Received for review from the author; all opinions are my own.

More Information About the Author (Provided by the Author)


Author Bio:
I'm a history professor by day, a novelist by night. I like to write what I read - fantasy, romantic fantasy, gothic fiction, historical fiction, paranormal, horror, and weird fiction. Horror cinema and horticulture are my other passions. When I’m not reading or writing or teaching, I'm gaming, traveling, baking, or adding some new weird creepy cool thing to my art collection. I’m a Long Island native with one husband, two children, and three rats.

Where to Find Me:

Blog: Lady Bathory’s Closet

Facebook

Instagram

Amazon Author Page

Goodreads



Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Books On My Fall 2025 To-Read List

It's already mid-fall, so I've already read some of these, but I imagine I'll finish more before the fall is out! I'm reading quite widely these days--I seem to be reading 3-6 books at any given time, because of book clubs, yes, but also mood, format, and availability. Happy Top Ten Tuesday! Books On My Fall 2025 To-Read List An Amateur Witch's Guide to Murder by K. Valentin--I received this ebook for review from LibraryThing, and I've never been quite so pleased with my choices! This was a hilarious ride from the get-go and crammed full of witchy Goth kid oddities and gore--a perfect Halloween read, and hopefully the beginning of a series! A Bridesmaid's Guide to Murder by Abigail Scott--Another ebook I received for review from LibraryThing--and whatever it is, books ending in "Guide to Murder" are killing it for me these days! (Let's not look too deep...) I'm not finished, but I'm loving it so far. Don't Forget to Write by Sara Go...

Cozy/Atmospheric Reads

I love this topic for rejoining Top Ten Tuesday!  I'm trying to lean in as much as possible to the coziness of fall and the upcoming winter season. I've done a lot better with that the last few years. Just because it isn't my favorite doesn't mean I can't enjoy it. Plus, some books I'm reading lately that are apropos for the Halloween atmosphere pervading my neighborhood this month at least.  Cozy/Atmospheric Reads Adenashire, a Cozy Fantasy Book Series by J. Penner--These books are the epitome of cozy fantasy with distinctive characters from a variety of creative fantasy backgrounds, including orcs, fennex, and gargoyles. The Bloodstained Key by Charity Rau--Not so cozy, but stiflingly atmospheric--a Gothic novel set inside a fairytale. The Unfortunate Side Effects of Heartbreak and Magic by Breanne Randall--Really captures the cozy atmosphere of a small town and a trove of magical family secrets. An Amateur Witch's Guide to Murder by K. Valentin--I don...

My Reactions to Common Book Buzzwords or Phrases

I'm trying to post but take it easy, so I'm including my reactions to some of the example buzzwords Jana used in the prompt, plus any more I think of. I had some very strong and immediate reactions, probably since these buzzwords are so common, especially in romance and the romantasy that's ultrapopular these days! Happy Top Ten Tuesday! My Reactions to Common Book Buzzwords or Phrases Phrase: "Morally grey characters" My Reaction: NO. Why?: I'm thoroughly sick of this trend, especially because it typically means "morally grey male love interest" which typically actually means "I fell in love with a serial killer BUT HE LOOOOVES ME." No. Don't get me wrong, I can and do enjoy genuinely nuanced characters and I do not expect anyone, much less a fictional character, to be perfect nor do I want them to be, but if I see that phrase, I think Rhysand, or, at best, Christian Grey, and I'm just not into that. (But if you are, you're ...